During the late 1920s and early 1930s, many influential progressives, including members of FDR's Brain Trust and other close advisers like Rexford Tugwell, Harold Ickes, and Stuart Chase couldn't wait to implement the economic planning of Russia, Germany, Italy, and Japan in America. Later, when knowledge of those nations' derogation of basic human rights, concentration camps, and the Gulag reached the light of day, progressives immediately began distancing themselves from their previous positions, at least, publicly. Those members of the general public that bought into the idea of government control of the economy fell into 2 groups: 1) the desperate, the poor, and the hungry who benefited from New Deal programs; and 2) those who may not have been the direct recipients of government handouts, but, nevertheless, believed that government provided the only path out of the Depression - in short, those who fed on a steady diet of pro-New Deal, pro-FDR propaganda. Both groups failed to comprehend the overwhelming weight of history: no government has been able to control the economy without exerting political control on its citizens. Freedom cannot be neatly compartmentalized into economic freedom and all other types of freedom - the concepts must go in hand. After all, what is more important than a man being able to work hard in a trade that he has chosen, being fairly compensated for his efforts, holding on to as much of those hard earned wages as possible, and spending it in the manner that he chooses? Economic freedom opens doorways to a better life. The head of the household does not have to worry about the fear of being unable to maintain a roof over his family's head and put food on the table. He can send his children to better schools, take family trips with them, enroll them in summer camp and pay for them to play sports. He can save for their education and his and his spouse's retirement.
If you take away economic freedom, then you become a slave to the whims of the state unless, of course, you belong to the ranks of the politically privileged. That concept, more than anything, has led to the economic ruin in which the world finds itself.
Although patronage has been a part of the American political landscape since the days of Andrew Jackson and Martin Van Buren, it was FDR who transformed it into a science. FDR understood that, once Americans realized the ineffectiveness of his policies and the sad state in which the economy wallowed, there was no way that he could win in an open and fair election. FDR's strategy was to create as many special interest groups as possible, ensure their loyalty by distributing taxpayer money to them, and then rely upon them to return the favor by re-electing him in perpetuity and donating to his campaign. How did he do it? He created agencies like the TVA which provided cheap electricity to certain areas of the country. The fact that the electricity was supported by taxes paid by people in other parts of the country was never really mentioned nor would it have mattered to the recipients of such largesse. FDR signed the Wagner Act into law which, by tilting the balance of power in favor of unions, led to 1000% growth in the number of Union workers - all of whom showed their appreciation by voting for FDR in national elections. FDR counted among his fans farmers, whom his programs subsidized (in fact, farmers were paid not to produce in order to drive up prices which further benefited them), academics (since he gave them jobs and a say in government), and the elderly and the retired (by creating Social Security). Everyone else, the so-called "Forgotten Man" of the 1940s, who did not benefit from government handouts, was left out on the cold. [Note: See William Sumner's quote - not the one that Roosevelt twisted for his own purposes].
The parallels with the Obama Administration are astounding. The members of his cabinet and the heads of the various government agencies with which he implements his policies are a microcosm of the broader group of special interest groups that form his core supporters: Wall Street bankers and hedge fund managers, academics, the unions, the youth, trial lawyers, and government employees. The stimulus was specifically designed to funnel taxpayer money into the coffers of those groups. Of course, those groups then turn around and repay Obama's magnanimity by donating to the DNC and to the President's reelection campaign (which, as of the date of this post, amounts to approximately $1 billion).
This is not how a republic functions. Instead, we are witnessing some bastardized form of direct democracy: the special interest groups elect their man who represents them exclusively - the rest of the nation be damned. Moreover, not only has our political system been transformed, our economy has experienced the same perversion: the stimulus bill, Obamacare, etc. are all redistributionist actions designed to only help the privileged few. It is as if the US has a two-tiered economy: on one level we find the special interest groups willing to play ball with the regime for financial gain and a second level of the virtually ignored who just happen to pay the tax dollars that support the other group. If we do not correct this imbalance of power and return to the principles of economics and government that created the greatest nation in the history of the world, then we will be doomed to an inferior existence, a mere extension of the economically weak and morally bankrupt Europe.
Lastly, as I mentioned above, the intelligentsia and social engineers have engaged in an enormous act of self-deception. In their blind pursuit of "change," whatever that term means, they have completely ignored the clear lessons of history. Those four (4) nations I listed at the beginning of my post all had planned economies. We fought a war against 3 of them and a cold war against the remaining one. The evidence is overwhelming that all 4 engaged in horrific acts of inhumanity, primarily against dissidents or those who were different. Eventually, the social planners will realize that they must firmly place their black boots on the necks of the opposition if they are ever going to realize their dreams of a socialist Utopia. Unfortunately for them, that fantasy never materializes and never will so long as the price is the end of human freedom.
Thomas Paine
Tuesday, July 12, 2011
Sunday, July 10, 2011
Where are the jobs?
The United States created a paltry 18,000 jobs in June and the unemployment rate increased to 9.2%. The number of long-term unemployed (those jobless for 27 weeks and over) sits at 6.3 million and accounts for 44.4% of the unemployed. Let that marinate for a while: almost half of all unemployed persons have been without a job for more than 6 months. Also, do you recall a few months ago how this Administration and its propagandists in the media trumpeted an alleged reduction trend in the jobless rate? The decrease in the jobless numbers apparently was not as reported. From the BLS website: "The change in total nonfarm payroll employment for April was revised from +232,000 to +217,000, and the change for May was revised from +54,000 to +25,000." The 15,000 discrepancy might be excused due to miscounting or slightly-off estimates, but being off by 29,000 (approximately 54% difference)? It appears as if someone is fudging on the figures.
So, in spite of the New Dealesque stimulus spending and over a trillion dollars in government bailouts, unemployment has not fallen lower than 8.8% since March 2009 - the date the original stimuls bill became law. The average unemployment rate under the Obama Administration has been 9.4% (I did not include January 2009 since the President did not take office until January 21, 2009). Unemployment has averaged 9.5% since the passage of the stimulus bill. For those who argue that we need to give the stimulus bill time to work, unemployment has averaged 9.5% for a period beginning 6 months after the stimulus bill was passed. It has averaged 9.4% for a period beginning 12 months after the bill passed.
The multi-trillion dollar question is: WHY?
Many bloggers and pundits blame corporate job outsourcing for the lack of jobs. The same group often bundles the ephemeral concept of hoarding with outsourcing in its condemnation of evil corporations.
If corporations are "hoarding," which I believe detractors define as "not spending greater money on employee compensation and not hiring new workers," then what is the reason for their failure to spend their cash reserves? One reason is that the US currently exists under a regime that plays favorites, only helps its friends (i.e. its pet special interest groups) and punishes its enemies (i.e. everyone not willing to play ball). If you do not have a multi-million dollar lobbying budget or cannot order hundreds of thousands of workers contribute to and vote for this President and his cronies in Congress, then you are insignificant. If, like the US Chamber of Commerce, Boeing, or Fox News, you attempt to challenge this President's agenda, then you will feel his wrath via a facilitating media or punitive legislation. How can you operate a business in that type of environment? How can you plan for the future, including determining whether you can hire more employees.
Moreover, the first 18 months of the Obama Administration has resulted in the passage of the most sweeping redistributionist legislation since the New Deal. Regulation continue to accumulate. Businesses are unable to determine their future finances because they have no way of determining whether or not some new law will pass in the near future that will result in higher compliance costs or a reduction in production (and revenue). This means that it would not be advisable for many businesses to take the risk of hiring new employees and spend the time and resources to train them if they only have to let them go in a few months because of a future increase in costs. In addition, those same businesses are equally reluctant to invest in capital goods because of potentially higher costs. That means there is less spending on big ticket items like buildings, equipment, and vehicles because the businesses do not know if they will be able to afford them in the future. Businesses' inability to predict their costs translates into an inability to obtain credit. After all, commercial lenders will not loan to businesses because they have no way of assessing their risk since the businesses themselves do not know what their costs will be. Along those same lines, in an environment in which lending money to businesses is much more risky (and other investments options like stocks, due to their volatility, or real estate, due to the collapse of prices, are rendered highly unattractive), they will invest in government securities since there is a guaranteed return. Said differently, banks will invest in treasury bonds because of their guaranteed return over running the risk of lending to a business that may default or file bankruptcy.
Because businesses are reluctant or, due to the inability to obtain credit, incapable of purchasing capital goods, it creates a snowball effect of ever-increasing unemployment. Less capital goods purchased means fewer revenue for manufacturers which means fewer manufacturing jobs. But the negative tidal wave does not end there. Fewer capital goods being made means that the producers of raw materials, transportation companies, wholesalers, salespeople, repairmen, etc. (together with all of the countless industries that support the various industries) all experience a drop in revenue. Less revenue means less money for capital goods purchases and hiring.
Lastly, in such an environment, one in which corporations are constantly demonized, investors who would otherwise run the risk of investing their money in shares, funds that corporations would have been able to use to purchase capital goods and hire employees, instead invest in other vehicles such as treasury bonds guaranteed by the full faith and credit of the United States government, or they save (i.e. investing in money market accounts, CDs, etc. - lower return but safer investments). Without investment, the economy suffers deleterious effects in other ways. There is less capital available to support innovation. In fact, the only investment in innovation is typically government subsidies that go to political favorites resulting in distortions in the economy, malinvestment (often creating bubbles), and inefficiencies (i.e. allocations of resources to areas that do not provide the maximum benefit to consumers or for the production of items that consumers neither want nor need).
So, in spite of the New Dealesque stimulus spending and over a trillion dollars in government bailouts, unemployment has not fallen lower than 8.8% since March 2009 - the date the original stimuls bill became law. The average unemployment rate under the Obama Administration has been 9.4% (I did not include January 2009 since the President did not take office until January 21, 2009). Unemployment has averaged 9.5% since the passage of the stimulus bill. For those who argue that we need to give the stimulus bill time to work, unemployment has averaged 9.5% for a period beginning 6 months after the stimulus bill was passed. It has averaged 9.4% for a period beginning 12 months after the bill passed.
The multi-trillion dollar question is: WHY?
Many bloggers and pundits blame corporate job outsourcing for the lack of jobs. The same group often bundles the ephemeral concept of hoarding with outsourcing in its condemnation of evil corporations.
If corporations are "hoarding," which I believe detractors define as "not spending greater money on employee compensation and not hiring new workers," then what is the reason for their failure to spend their cash reserves? One reason is that the US currently exists under a regime that plays favorites, only helps its friends (i.e. its pet special interest groups) and punishes its enemies (i.e. everyone not willing to play ball). If you do not have a multi-million dollar lobbying budget or cannot order hundreds of thousands of workers contribute to and vote for this President and his cronies in Congress, then you are insignificant. If, like the US Chamber of Commerce, Boeing, or Fox News, you attempt to challenge this President's agenda, then you will feel his wrath via a facilitating media or punitive legislation. How can you operate a business in that type of environment? How can you plan for the future, including determining whether you can hire more employees.
Moreover, the first 18 months of the Obama Administration has resulted in the passage of the most sweeping redistributionist legislation since the New Deal. Regulation continue to accumulate. Businesses are unable to determine their future finances because they have no way of determining whether or not some new law will pass in the near future that will result in higher compliance costs or a reduction in production (and revenue). This means that it would not be advisable for many businesses to take the risk of hiring new employees and spend the time and resources to train them if they only have to let them go in a few months because of a future increase in costs. In addition, those same businesses are equally reluctant to invest in capital goods because of potentially higher costs. That means there is less spending on big ticket items like buildings, equipment, and vehicles because the businesses do not know if they will be able to afford them in the future. Businesses' inability to predict their costs translates into an inability to obtain credit. After all, commercial lenders will not loan to businesses because they have no way of assessing their risk since the businesses themselves do not know what their costs will be. Along those same lines, in an environment in which lending money to businesses is much more risky (and other investments options like stocks, due to their volatility, or real estate, due to the collapse of prices, are rendered highly unattractive), they will invest in government securities since there is a guaranteed return. Said differently, banks will invest in treasury bonds because of their guaranteed return over running the risk of lending to a business that may default or file bankruptcy.
Because businesses are reluctant or, due to the inability to obtain credit, incapable of purchasing capital goods, it creates a snowball effect of ever-increasing unemployment. Less capital goods purchased means fewer revenue for manufacturers which means fewer manufacturing jobs. But the negative tidal wave does not end there. Fewer capital goods being made means that the producers of raw materials, transportation companies, wholesalers, salespeople, repairmen, etc. (together with all of the countless industries that support the various industries) all experience a drop in revenue. Less revenue means less money for capital goods purchases and hiring.
Lastly, in such an environment, one in which corporations are constantly demonized, investors who would otherwise run the risk of investing their money in shares, funds that corporations would have been able to use to purchase capital goods and hire employees, instead invest in other vehicles such as treasury bonds guaranteed by the full faith and credit of the United States government, or they save (i.e. investing in money market accounts, CDs, etc. - lower return but safer investments). Without investment, the economy suffers deleterious effects in other ways. There is less capital available to support innovation. In fact, the only investment in innovation is typically government subsidies that go to political favorites resulting in distortions in the economy, malinvestment (often creating bubbles), and inefficiencies (i.e. allocations of resources to areas that do not provide the maximum benefit to consumers or for the production of items that consumers neither want nor need).
The argument that the 14th Amendment allows the Treasury Department to borrow as much money as it wants is hogwash
From the National Review Online:
July 4, 2011 4:00 A.M.
Obama’s Spendthrift Constitution
Congress, not the president, authorizes new borrowing.
All those pesky people attempting to tie raising the debt limit to reducing the debt through spending cuts must be unreconstructed southerners. How so? Well, they are clearly obstructing the president’s efforts to enforce the 14th amendment!
A constitutional claim newly minted by some administration asserts that the president can raise the debt ceiling if Congress doesn’t. This novel claim rests on Section 4 of the 14th Amendment, which says:
The validity of the public debt of the United States, authorized by law, including debts incurred for payment of pensions and bounties for services in suppressing insurrection or rebellion, shall not be questioned. But neither the United States nor any State shall assume or pay any debt or obligation incurred in aid of insurrection or rebellion against the United States, or any claim for the loss or emancipation of any slave; but all such debts, obligations and claims shall be held illegal and void.
The argument claims: (1) The federal government is constitutionally prohibited from defaulting on its debt; (2) therefore, Congress must raise the debt ceiling in order to avoid a default; and (3) if Congress refuses to do so, the 14th Amendment’s Section 4 impliedly allows the president to authorize the issuance of additional debt.
For many liberal constitutional-law professors — including former constitutional-law professor Barack Obama — the 14th Amendment is the only part of the Constitution that really matters. Still, even if the rest of the Constitution did not exist, Section 4’s language could not support this argument.
The argument blurs the meaning of “public debt.” It fails to distinguish deficit spending from issuing debt instruments to cover that deficit.
No one has questioned the federal government’s obligations to pay the debt instruments already issued — Treasury notes, bills, and bonds held by investors and foreign governments. Congress has authorized issuance of debt instruments of up to $14.29 trillion.
The controversy concerns whether Congress will authorize the Treasury to issue additional debt instruments. Section 4 specifies “public debt of the United States, authorized by law” (emphasis added). Only Congress — not the president — makes laws. Nothing in Section 4 requires Congress to “authorize[] by law” any additional debt.
Nevertheless, some who claim Section 4 supports implied presidential powers cite dicta in the Supreme Court’s plurality opinion in Perry v. U.S. (1935). This case involved a Treasury bond written as “payable in United States gold coin,” which the Treasury refused to pay in gold after Congress barred gold payments in 1933. In reality, the plurality opinion’s discussion of Section 4 cuts against arguments for expanded presidential power. It states:
We regard [Section 4] as confirmatory of a fundamental principle, which applies as well to the government bonds in question, and to others duly authorized by the Congress, as to those issued before the Amendment was adopted. Nor can we perceive any reason for not considering the expression “the validity of the public debt” as embracing whatever concerns the integrity of the public obligations. [Emphasis added.]
Perry confirms that Section 4 deals with debt “duly authorized by Congress.”
Even if Congress refused to pay debts already authorized — which no one is suggesting — the president could not provide a remedy. As the Perry plurality also stated, Congress has no duty to provide a remedy: “While the Congress is under no duty to provide remedies through the courts, the contractual obligation still exists and, despite infirmities of procedure, remains binding upon the conscience of the sovereign [emphasis added].”
Obligations “binding on the conscience” are also recognized by Article VI of the Constitution. It obligates the payment of “All Debts” incurred under the Confederation. Nevertheless, both that provision and Section 4 rely on Congress’s power “to borrow money on credit of the United States” (Article I, Section 8).
The struggle between House Republicans, who insist on spending cuts, and the president, who advocates higher taxes, simply exemplifies our separation-of-powers system in action. By design, the system usually forces resolutions of policy conflicts through some kind of compromise. And if the president and Congress fail to reach an agreement, the Constitution has not left the president powerless. As Senator Toomey insists, the Treasury can easily pay interest to bondholders first. The remaining funds would cover about two-thirds of the budget, and the president would simply be forced to make drastic cuts because he lacked money to pay all the bills.
Ultimately, public opinion will dictate whether a compromise occurs and whether spending cuts or tax increases prevail. That is as it should be in a self-governing republic.
On the debt ceiling, House Republicans have both the moral and the constitutional high ground. The 14th Amendment’s Section 4 and Article VI recognize the general obligation “binding upon the conscience of the sovereign” to pay lawful debts. Congress — not the president — decides the lawful debt level under its Article I power to borrow. Section 4 cannot imply novel presidential powers of enforcement because Section 5 provides: “The Congress shall have power to enforce, by appropriate legislation, the provisions of this article.”
The Congress need not even pass legislation requiring that current debt holders be paid first. Nor should House Republicans be intimidated by the Section 4 argument. In fact, they should use it against the president. The argument recognizes the president’s obligation to pay existing debt instruments. He can do so regardless of whether Congress raises the debt limit.
July 4, 2011 4:00 A.M.
Obama’s Spendthrift Constitution
Congress, not the president, authorizes new borrowing.
All those pesky people attempting to tie raising the debt limit to reducing the debt through spending cuts must be unreconstructed southerners. How so? Well, they are clearly obstructing the president’s efforts to enforce the 14th amendment!
A constitutional claim newly minted by some administration asserts that the president can raise the debt ceiling if Congress doesn’t. This novel claim rests on Section 4 of the 14th Amendment, which says:
The validity of the public debt of the United States, authorized by law, including debts incurred for payment of pensions and bounties for services in suppressing insurrection or rebellion, shall not be questioned. But neither the United States nor any State shall assume or pay any debt or obligation incurred in aid of insurrection or rebellion against the United States, or any claim for the loss or emancipation of any slave; but all such debts, obligations and claims shall be held illegal and void.
The argument claims: (1) The federal government is constitutionally prohibited from defaulting on its debt; (2) therefore, Congress must raise the debt ceiling in order to avoid a default; and (3) if Congress refuses to do so, the 14th Amendment’s Section 4 impliedly allows the president to authorize the issuance of additional debt.
For many liberal constitutional-law professors — including former constitutional-law professor Barack Obama — the 14th Amendment is the only part of the Constitution that really matters. Still, even if the rest of the Constitution did not exist, Section 4’s language could not support this argument.
The argument blurs the meaning of “public debt.” It fails to distinguish deficit spending from issuing debt instruments to cover that deficit.
No one has questioned the federal government’s obligations to pay the debt instruments already issued — Treasury notes, bills, and bonds held by investors and foreign governments. Congress has authorized issuance of debt instruments of up to $14.29 trillion.
The controversy concerns whether Congress will authorize the Treasury to issue additional debt instruments. Section 4 specifies “public debt of the United States, authorized by law” (emphasis added). Only Congress — not the president — makes laws. Nothing in Section 4 requires Congress to “authorize[] by law” any additional debt.
Nevertheless, some who claim Section 4 supports implied presidential powers cite dicta in the Supreme Court’s plurality opinion in Perry v. U.S. (1935). This case involved a Treasury bond written as “payable in United States gold coin,” which the Treasury refused to pay in gold after Congress barred gold payments in 1933. In reality, the plurality opinion’s discussion of Section 4 cuts against arguments for expanded presidential power. It states:
We regard [Section 4] as confirmatory of a fundamental principle, which applies as well to the government bonds in question, and to others duly authorized by the Congress, as to those issued before the Amendment was adopted. Nor can we perceive any reason for not considering the expression “the validity of the public debt” as embracing whatever concerns the integrity of the public obligations. [Emphasis added.]
Perry confirms that Section 4 deals with debt “duly authorized by Congress.”
Even if Congress refused to pay debts already authorized — which no one is suggesting — the president could not provide a remedy. As the Perry plurality also stated, Congress has no duty to provide a remedy: “While the Congress is under no duty to provide remedies through the courts, the contractual obligation still exists and, despite infirmities of procedure, remains binding upon the conscience of the sovereign [emphasis added].”
Obligations “binding on the conscience” are also recognized by Article VI of the Constitution. It obligates the payment of “All Debts” incurred under the Confederation. Nevertheless, both that provision and Section 4 rely on Congress’s power “to borrow money on credit of the United States” (Article I, Section 8).
The struggle between House Republicans, who insist on spending cuts, and the president, who advocates higher taxes, simply exemplifies our separation-of-powers system in action. By design, the system usually forces resolutions of policy conflicts through some kind of compromise. And if the president and Congress fail to reach an agreement, the Constitution has not left the president powerless. As Senator Toomey insists, the Treasury can easily pay interest to bondholders first. The remaining funds would cover about two-thirds of the budget, and the president would simply be forced to make drastic cuts because he lacked money to pay all the bills.
Ultimately, public opinion will dictate whether a compromise occurs and whether spending cuts or tax increases prevail. That is as it should be in a self-governing republic.
On the debt ceiling, House Republicans have both the moral and the constitutional high ground. The 14th Amendment’s Section 4 and Article VI recognize the general obligation “binding upon the conscience of the sovereign” to pay lawful debts. Congress — not the president — decides the lawful debt level under its Article I power to borrow. Section 4 cannot imply novel presidential powers of enforcement because Section 5 provides: “The Congress shall have power to enforce, by appropriate legislation, the provisions of this article.”
The Congress need not even pass legislation requiring that current debt holders be paid first. Nor should House Republicans be intimidated by the Section 4 argument. In fact, they should use it against the president. The argument recognizes the president’s obligation to pay existing debt instruments. He can do so regardless of whether Congress raises the debt limit.
Wednesday, July 6, 2011
Wednesday, May 4, 2011
Osama Bin Laden is dead...now what?
You can't help but be elated over OBL's death at the hands of 6 US Navy SEALs. In some ways, it is as if America has awoken from a dream and found out that Freddy Krueger is finally dead. There will be "deathers" attempting to cast doubt on whether or not he is actually dead or still in hiding somewhere (it has happened with Hitler, Elvis, and a number of others). There will be alternative versions of how the assault went down. Many now comment that Pakistan - an alleged ally - must have been harboring Bin Laden since he spent 6 years approximately 1000 yards away from the Pakistani military academy without detection. What do you say we celebrate his death for a few days...and then get back to business? Forget conspiracy theories, don't fixate on the logistics and minutiae, and avoid attributing the success of the operation to any one person or group of people. Instead, understand that the death of one man - even one whose mere name carries so much significance and symbolism - doesn't change the fact that we still face the same insidious threat to our liberty from those who would supplant our constitutional republican form of government and our free market economy, people who hate our very existence and patiently work towards bringing down the entire house of cards. The Middle East is a boiling cauldron of chaos and will be for some time - OBL or no OBL.
Sunday, March 13, 2011
Analyzing the Mind of the Left - pt. 5
Lewis's makes the following reference to Fanon: "To Franz Fanon, a rebirth of consciousness was necessary, a violent reawakening to the basic rights and responsibilities that are every human being's birthright. That decades of seemingly thuggish stability could be blasted apart so quickly in Egypt speaks to the fragility of that consciousness of suppression. Fanon spoke to a different era, for in these events we see that no existential cataclysm was required."
"Existential cataclysm?" Indulge in melodrama much, do we Mr. Lewis? What does that phrase mean exactly? Is this combination of words tautological? "Existential" means pertaining to existence. Cataclysm, in Lewis's context, means "any violent upheaval, especially one of a social or political nature." Accordingly, lumped together, the words mean a violent upheaval pertaining to one's existence? Can there be any other type of violent upheaval? But I digress...
Now to my point, followers of Fanon make the same mistake often committed by followers of Marx: they re-package their spiritual mentor's theories into what they believe the guy meant, in essence, imbuing the original texts with meanings that simply aren't there. This is particular so with regards to modern socialists' interpretations of Marx's theories of economics.
In the present case, Lewis implies that Fanon advocated a collective "rebirth of consciousness" as the means of escaping colonialist/imperialist oppression. In reality, Fanon advocated nationalism as the foundation of developing a collective identity:
"The nation is not only the condition of culture, its fruitfulness, its
continuous renewal, and its deepening. It is also a necessity. It is the
fight for national existence which sets culture moving and opens to it
the doors of creation. Later on it is the nation which will ensure the
conditions and framework necessary to culture...Far from keeping aloof from other nations, therefore, it is national liberation which leads the nation to play its part on the stage of history. "
Marxists like Lewis cannot attribute nationalistic tendencies to a Marxist hero like Fanon for two reasons: 1) Socialism is intended to be an international and universal system. It will not succeed unless the entire world converts to socialism; and 2) nationalism is the purview of the Nazis and other fascists. So, Lewis projects his own interpretations (or, the more likely scenario, Lewis' poli sci professor interpreted Fanon and Lewis absorbed that interpretation as the gospel). Interestingly, the original nationalist movement which surfaced in France during the French Revolution, with its emphasis on the collective and the rights of all mankind, is one of the primary inspirations of Marxist thought.
How close does Fanon approximate Hitler? Consider this quote from Mein Kampf:
"All the human culture, all the results of art, science, and technology that we see before us today, are almost exclusively the creative product of the Aryan. This very fact admits of the not unfounded inference that he alone was the founder of all higher humanity, therefore representing the prototype of all that we understand by the word "man." He is the Prometheus of mankind from whose bright forehead the divine spark of genius has sprung at all times.... Exclude him and perhaps after a few thousand years darkness will again descend on the earth, human culture will pass, and the world turn to a desert. Human culture and civilization on this continent are inseparably bound up with the presence of the Aryan. If he dies out or declines, the dark veils of an age without culture will again descend on this globe."
Some will balk at the idea of comparing Fanon's ideas regarding African nationalism to Hitler's Aryanism, but, before you discount my comments, consider the reference in the article I copied in a previous post: Fanon was a protege of Aime Cesaire, one of, if not, the progenitor of the Negritude movement. Negritude was a form of black consciousness and racial solidarity against French colonial racism. It is as race-based as Aryanism. From Black Skin, White Masks:
"The Negro is aiming for the universal, but on the screen his Negro essence, his Negro 'nature,' is kept intact: . . . I have barely opened my eyes that had been blindfolded, and someone already wants to drown me in the universal? . . . I need to lose myself in my negritude, to see the fires, the segregations, the repressions, the rapes, the discriminations, the boycotts. We need to put our fingers on every sore that mottles the black uniform. . . . It is my belief that a true culture cannot come to life under present conditions. It will time enough to talk of the black genius when the man has regained his rightful place."
To summarize, the pantheon of the Left must remain inviolate and virginal in its purity at all costs. Since many of its icons are ahistorical, common sense averse, and self-contradictory, it is incumbent upon the priests of the Left to fill in the gaps where necessary to ensure that the overall narrative is preserved. This clergy interprets the words of the deities for the masses from their Delphic oracles (aka post-secondary institutions of lower learning). [An aside: although the comparison of the Left's monopoly on divine "truth" to the oracles of ancient Greece holds true, an identical comparison could be made to the Dark Age Catholic church]. As a result, the useful idiots on the Left frequently fail to read their own holy writ.
Also, there is often little ideological difference between the radicals on the Left and the radicals on the Right. Fanon may have joined the French army to fight Hitler, but, when he returned to peacetime Algiers, his soon to be acquired radical ideas that appear very similar to Hitler's. Of course, since the Left's narrative is that oppressed minorities, by their very natures, cannot be racist, confronting the Left with examples of these similarities will only fall on deaf ears.
"Existential cataclysm?" Indulge in melodrama much, do we Mr. Lewis? What does that phrase mean exactly? Is this combination of words tautological? "Existential" means pertaining to existence. Cataclysm, in Lewis's context, means "any violent upheaval, especially one of a social or political nature." Accordingly, lumped together, the words mean a violent upheaval pertaining to one's existence? Can there be any other type of violent upheaval? But I digress...
Now to my point, followers of Fanon make the same mistake often committed by followers of Marx: they re-package their spiritual mentor's theories into what they believe the guy meant, in essence, imbuing the original texts with meanings that simply aren't there. This is particular so with regards to modern socialists' interpretations of Marx's theories of economics.
In the present case, Lewis implies that Fanon advocated a collective "rebirth of consciousness" as the means of escaping colonialist/imperialist oppression. In reality, Fanon advocated nationalism as the foundation of developing a collective identity:
"The nation is not only the condition of culture, its fruitfulness, its
continuous renewal, and its deepening. It is also a necessity. It is the
fight for national existence which sets culture moving and opens to it
the doors of creation. Later on it is the nation which will ensure the
conditions and framework necessary to culture...Far from keeping aloof from other nations, therefore, it is national liberation which leads the nation to play its part on the stage of history. "
Marxists like Lewis cannot attribute nationalistic tendencies to a Marxist hero like Fanon for two reasons: 1) Socialism is intended to be an international and universal system. It will not succeed unless the entire world converts to socialism; and 2) nationalism is the purview of the Nazis and other fascists. So, Lewis projects his own interpretations (or, the more likely scenario, Lewis' poli sci professor interpreted Fanon and Lewis absorbed that interpretation as the gospel). Interestingly, the original nationalist movement which surfaced in France during the French Revolution, with its emphasis on the collective and the rights of all mankind, is one of the primary inspirations of Marxist thought.
How close does Fanon approximate Hitler? Consider this quote from Mein Kampf:
"All the human culture, all the results of art, science, and technology that we see before us today, are almost exclusively the creative product of the Aryan. This very fact admits of the not unfounded inference that he alone was the founder of all higher humanity, therefore representing the prototype of all that we understand by the word "man." He is the Prometheus of mankind from whose bright forehead the divine spark of genius has sprung at all times.... Exclude him and perhaps after a few thousand years darkness will again descend on the earth, human culture will pass, and the world turn to a desert. Human culture and civilization on this continent are inseparably bound up with the presence of the Aryan. If he dies out or declines, the dark veils of an age without culture will again descend on this globe."
Some will balk at the idea of comparing Fanon's ideas regarding African nationalism to Hitler's Aryanism, but, before you discount my comments, consider the reference in the article I copied in a previous post: Fanon was a protege of Aime Cesaire, one of, if not, the progenitor of the Negritude movement. Negritude was a form of black consciousness and racial solidarity against French colonial racism. It is as race-based as Aryanism. From Black Skin, White Masks:
"The Negro is aiming for the universal, but on the screen his Negro essence, his Negro 'nature,' is kept intact: . . . I have barely opened my eyes that had been blindfolded, and someone already wants to drown me in the universal? . . . I need to lose myself in my negritude, to see the fires, the segregations, the repressions, the rapes, the discriminations, the boycotts. We need to put our fingers on every sore that mottles the black uniform. . . . It is my belief that a true culture cannot come to life under present conditions. It will time enough to talk of the black genius when the man has regained his rightful place."
To summarize, the pantheon of the Left must remain inviolate and virginal in its purity at all costs. Since many of its icons are ahistorical, common sense averse, and self-contradictory, it is incumbent upon the priests of the Left to fill in the gaps where necessary to ensure that the overall narrative is preserved. This clergy interprets the words of the deities for the masses from their Delphic oracles (aka post-secondary institutions of lower learning). [An aside: although the comparison of the Left's monopoly on divine "truth" to the oracles of ancient Greece holds true, an identical comparison could be made to the Dark Age Catholic church]. As a result, the useful idiots on the Left frequently fail to read their own holy writ.
Also, there is often little ideological difference between the radicals on the Left and the radicals on the Right. Fanon may have joined the French army to fight Hitler, but, when he returned to peacetime Algiers, his soon to be acquired radical ideas that appear very similar to Hitler's. Of course, since the Left's narrative is that oppressed minorities, by their very natures, cannot be racist, confronting the Left with examples of these similarities will only fall on deaf ears.
Sunday, March 6, 2011
Analyzing the Mind of the Left: pt. 4
We move now to Mr. Lewis's reference to Frantz Fanon. To understand the importance of this reference, you need to know more about the man. The following is from www.absoluteastronomy.com:
"Frantz Omar Fanon (July 20, 1925 – December 6, 1961) was a French psychiatrist and author, born in Martinique. His work remains influential in the fields of post-colonial studies and critical theory. Fanon is known as a Marxist thinker on the issue of decolonization of colonization. His works have incited and inspired anti-colonial liberation movements for more than four decades.
Martinique and World War II
Frantz Fanon was born on the Caribbean island of Martinique, which was then a French colony and is now a French département. He was born into a mixed family background: his father was the descendent of African slaves, and his mother was said to be an illegitimate child of mixed race, whose white ancestors came from Strasbourg. Fanon's family was socioeconomically middle-class, and they could afford the fees for the Lycée Schoelcher, then the most prestigious high school in Martinique, where the writer Aimé Césaire was one of his teachers.
After France fell to the Nazis in 1940, Vichy French naval troops were blockaded on Martinique. Forced to remain on the island, French soldiers became "authentic racists." Many accusations of harassment and sexual misconduct arose. The abuse of the Martiniquan people by the French Army was a major influence on Fanon, as it reinforced his feelings of alienation and his disgust at the realities of colonial racism. At the age of eighteen, Fanon fled the island as a "dissident" (the coined word for French West Indians joining the gaullist forces) and traveled to then-British colony to join the Free French ForcesFree French Forces. He later enlisted in the French army and joined an Allied convoy that arrived in Casablanca. He was later transferred to an army base at Bejaia on the Kabyle coast of Algeria. Fanon left Algeria from Oran and saw service in France. In 1944 he was wounded at Colmar and received the Croix de Guerre medal. When the Nazis were defeated and Allied forces crossed the Rhine, along with photo journalists, Fanon's regiment was 'bleached' of all non-white soldiers and Fanon and his fellow Caribbean soldiers were sent to Toulon (Provence) instead. Later, they were transferred to Normandy to await repatriation home.
In 1945 Fanon returned to Martinique. His return lasted only a short time. While there, he worked for the parliamentary campaign of his friend and mentor Aimé Césaire, who would be the greatest influence in his life. Although Fanon never professed to be a communist, Césaire ran on the communist ticket. Fanon stayed long enough to complete his Baccalaureate and then went to France where he studied medicine. He was educated in Lyon where he also studied literature, drama and philosophy, sometimes attending Merleau-Ponty's lectures. During this period he wrote three plays, whose manuscripts are now lost. After qualifying as a psychiatrist in 1951, Fanon did a residency in psychiatry at Saint-Alban under the radical Catalan psychiatrist Francois Tosquelles, who invigorated Fanon's thinking by emphasizing the important yet often overlooked role of culture in psychopathology. After his residency, Fanon practiced psychiatry at Pontorson, near Mont St Michel, for another year and then (from 1953) in Algeria. He was chef de service at the Blida-Joinville Psychiatric Hospital in Algeria, where he stayed until his deportation in January 1957.
His service in France's army (and his experiences in Martinique) influenced Black Skin, White Masks. For Fanon, being colonized by a language had larger implications for one's political consciousness: "To speak . . . means above all to assume a culture, to support the weight of a civilization" (BSWM 17-18). Speaking French means that one accepts, or is coerced into accepting, the collective consciousness of the French.
France
While in France, Fanon then wrote his first book in 1952, Black Skin, White Masks. In this study, Fanon uses psychoanalysis and psychoanalytical theory to explain the feelings of dependency and inadequacy that Black people experience in a White world, an analysis of the effect of colonial subjugation on humanity. This book was originally his doctoral thesis submitted at Lyon and entitled, "The Disalienation of the Black Man". The rejection of the thesis led Fanon to seek to have the book published. It was the left wing philosopher Francis Jeanson, leader of the pro-Algerian independence, who insisted on the new title and also wrote an epilogue for this publication.
Algeria
Fanon left France for Algeria, where he had been stationed for some time during the war. He secured an appointment as a psychiatrist at Blida-Joinville Psychiatric Hospital. It was there that he radicalized methods of treatment. In particular, he began socio-therapy which connected with his patients' cultural backgrounds. He also trained nurses and interns. Following the outbreak of the Algerian revolution in November 1954 he joined the FLN liberation front (Front de Libération Nationale) as a result of contacts with Dr. Pierre Chaulet at Blida in 1955.
In The Wretched of the Earth (Les damnés de la terre), published shortly before Fanon's death in 1961, Fanon discusses in depth the effects on Algerians of torture by the French forces. His book was then censored by the French government.
Fanon made extensive trips across Algeria, mainly in the Kabyle region, to study the cultural and psychological life of Algerians. His lost study of "The marabout of Si Slimane" is an example. These trips were also a means for clandestine activities, notably in his visits to the ski resort of Chrea which hid an FLN base. By summer 1956 he wrote his "Letter of resignation to the Resident Minister" and made a clean break with his French assimilationist upbringing and education. He was expelled from Algeria in January 1957 and the "nest of fellaghas [rebels]" at Blida hospital was dismantled.
Fanon left for France and subsequently traveled secretly to Tunis. He was part of the editorial collective of El Moudjahid for which he wrote to the end of his life. He also served as Ambassador to Ghana for the Provisional Algerian Government and attended conferences in Accra, Conakry, Addis Ababa, Leopoldville, Cairo and Tripoli. Many of his shorter writings from this period were collected posthumously in the book Toward the African Revolution. In this book Fanon reveals himself as a war strategist; in one chapter he discusses how to open a southern front to the war and how to run the supply lines.
Death
On his return to Tunis, after his exhausting trip across the Sahara
to open a Third Front, Fanon was diagnosed with leukemia. He went to the Soviet Union for treatment and experienced some remission of his illness. On his return to Tunis he dictated his testament The Wretched of the EarthThe Wretched of the Earth. When he was not confined to his bed, he delivered lectures to ALN (Armée de Libération Nationale) officers at Ghardimao on the Algero-Tunisian border. He made a final visit to Sartre in Rome and went for further leukemia treatment in the USA.
He died in Bethesda, Maryland, on December 6, 1961 under the name of Ibrahim Fanon. He was buried in Algeria, after lying in state in Tunisia. Later his body was moved to a martyrs (chouhada) graveyard at Ain Kerma
in eastern Algeria. Fanon was survived by his wife Josie (née Dublé), their son Olivier, and his daughter (from a previous relationship) Mireille. Mireille married Bernard Mendès-France, son of the French politician Pierre Mendès-France. Josie committed suicide in Algiers in 1989.
Work
Although Fanon wrote Black Skin, White Masks while still in France, most of his work was written while in North Africa. It was during this time that he produced works such as L'An Cinq, de la Révolution Algérienne, or Year Five of the Algerian Revolution, later republished as 'Sociology of a Revolution" and later still as 'A Dying Colonialism'. The irony of this was that Fanon's original title was "Reality of a Nation", however the publisher, Francois Maspero, refused to accept this title. He also wrote an important work on decolonization. The Wretched of the Earth was first published in 1961 by François Maspero and has a preface by Jean-Paul Sartre. In it Fanon analyzes the role of class, race, national culture and violence in the struggle for national liberation. Both books established Fanon in the eyes of much of the Third World as the leading anti-colonial thinker of the 20th century.
Fanon's three books were supplemented by numerous psychiatry articles as well as radical critiques of French colonialism in journals such as Esprit and El Moudjahid.
The reception of his work has been affected by English translations which are recognized to contain numerous omissions and errors, while his unpublished work, including his doctoral thesis, has received little attention. As a result, Fanon has often been portrayed as an advocate of violence. This reductionist vision of Fanon's work ignores the subtlety of his understanding of the colonial system.
For Fanon in The Wretched of the Earth, the colonizer's presence in Algeria is based sheerly on military strength. Any resistance to this strength must also be of a violent nature because it is the only 'language' the colonizer speaks. The relevance of language and the reformation of discourse pervades much of his work, which is why it is so interdisciplinary, spanning psychiatric concerns to encompass politics, sociology, anthropology, linguistics and literature.
His participation in the Algerian FLN from 1955 determined his audience as the Algerian colonized. It was to them that his final work, Les damnés de la terre (translated into English by Constance Farrington as The Wretched of the Earth) was directed. It constitutes a warning to the oppressed of the dangers they face in the whirlwind of decolonization and the transition to a neo-colonialist/globalized world.
Influences
Much of Fanon's writings is traced to the influence of Aimé Césaire. But, while it could be said that Fanon's works are directly influenced by the Négritude movement, Fanon reformulated the theory of Césaire and Léopold Senghor by positing a new theory of consciousness. Négritude implicitly based consciousness in racial difference and tension. A mean to achieve equality and remain under French rule without losing one’s identity through assimilation. Fanon's psychological training and experience influenced him to base much of the problems he saw as psychological and as the product of the domination which arises in oppressive colonial situations. That is, consciousness was not of "racial essence" but a fact arising from political and social situations. Fanon's consciousness was not purely black, but extended to colonized peoples of any racial category. Fanon's own explanation of the difference between his theory and that of Blaise Diagne, Senghor and Césaire was based in an evolutionary model where the colonized ideologies transition from assimiliationist, négritude, and finally Fanon's own theory.
Influence
Fanon has had an influence on anti-colonial and national liberation movements. In particular, Les damnés de la terre was a major influence on the work of revolutionary leaders such as Ali Shariati in Iran, Steve Biko in South Africa, Malcolm X in the United States and Ernesto Che Guevara in Cuba. Of these only Guevara was primarily concerned with Fanon's theories on violence; for Shariati and Biko the main interest in Fanon was "the new man" and "black consciousness" respectively. Fanon's influence extended to the liberation movements of the Palestinians, the Tamils and others. His work was a key influence on the Black Panther Party. More recently, radical South African people's movements have been influenced by Fanon's work. His work was a key influence on Brazilian educationist Paulo Freire. Barack Obama references Fanon in his book, Dreams From My Father."
I have no reason to doubt the veracity of the biographical portion of this article. I cannot say the same with the analysis part of the article.
Before proceeding with my analysis of Lewis's article and its connection to Fanon, one term in the biographical article has to be defined: critical theory. The term "critical theory," at times, is improperly used as a general term describing any theory founded on critique. However, in its proper context, critical theory is a Marxist theory that draws upon all of the social sciences and humanities in making a critique of society and culture. The "theory" part is somewhat of a misnomer since Marxism, as a general rule, does not rely on science or the scientific method, especially with regards to economics.
Now that you have a background on Fanon, we will discuss his theories in my next post. In the meantime, should you want to read Fanon, you can find the full text of The Wretched of the Earth here: http://www.questia.com/PM.qst?a=o&d=9701586.
"Frantz Omar Fanon (July 20, 1925 – December 6, 1961) was a French psychiatrist and author, born in Martinique. His work remains influential in the fields of post-colonial studies and critical theory. Fanon is known as a Marxist thinker on the issue of decolonization of colonization. His works have incited and inspired anti-colonial liberation movements for more than four decades.
Martinique and World War II
Frantz Fanon was born on the Caribbean island of Martinique, which was then a French colony and is now a French département. He was born into a mixed family background: his father was the descendent of African slaves, and his mother was said to be an illegitimate child of mixed race, whose white ancestors came from Strasbourg. Fanon's family was socioeconomically middle-class, and they could afford the fees for the Lycée Schoelcher, then the most prestigious high school in Martinique, where the writer Aimé Césaire was one of his teachers.
After France fell to the Nazis in 1940, Vichy French naval troops were blockaded on Martinique. Forced to remain on the island, French soldiers became "authentic racists." Many accusations of harassment and sexual misconduct arose. The abuse of the Martiniquan people by the French Army was a major influence on Fanon, as it reinforced his feelings of alienation and his disgust at the realities of colonial racism. At the age of eighteen, Fanon fled the island as a "dissident" (the coined word for French West Indians joining the gaullist forces) and traveled to then-British colony to join the Free French ForcesFree French Forces. He later enlisted in the French army and joined an Allied convoy that arrived in Casablanca. He was later transferred to an army base at Bejaia on the Kabyle coast of Algeria. Fanon left Algeria from Oran and saw service in France. In 1944 he was wounded at Colmar and received the Croix de Guerre medal. When the Nazis were defeated and Allied forces crossed the Rhine, along with photo journalists, Fanon's regiment was 'bleached' of all non-white soldiers and Fanon and his fellow Caribbean soldiers were sent to Toulon (Provence) instead. Later, they were transferred to Normandy to await repatriation home.
In 1945 Fanon returned to Martinique. His return lasted only a short time. While there, he worked for the parliamentary campaign of his friend and mentor Aimé Césaire, who would be the greatest influence in his life. Although Fanon never professed to be a communist, Césaire ran on the communist ticket. Fanon stayed long enough to complete his Baccalaureate and then went to France where he studied medicine. He was educated in Lyon where he also studied literature, drama and philosophy, sometimes attending Merleau-Ponty's lectures. During this period he wrote three plays, whose manuscripts are now lost. After qualifying as a psychiatrist in 1951, Fanon did a residency in psychiatry at Saint-Alban under the radical Catalan psychiatrist Francois Tosquelles, who invigorated Fanon's thinking by emphasizing the important yet often overlooked role of culture in psychopathology. After his residency, Fanon practiced psychiatry at Pontorson, near Mont St Michel, for another year and then (from 1953) in Algeria. He was chef de service at the Blida-Joinville Psychiatric Hospital in Algeria, where he stayed until his deportation in January 1957.
His service in France's army (and his experiences in Martinique) influenced Black Skin, White Masks. For Fanon, being colonized by a language had larger implications for one's political consciousness: "To speak . . . means above all to assume a culture, to support the weight of a civilization" (BSWM 17-18). Speaking French means that one accepts, or is coerced into accepting, the collective consciousness of the French.
France
While in France, Fanon then wrote his first book in 1952, Black Skin, White Masks. In this study, Fanon uses psychoanalysis and psychoanalytical theory to explain the feelings of dependency and inadequacy that Black people experience in a White world, an analysis of the effect of colonial subjugation on humanity. This book was originally his doctoral thesis submitted at Lyon and entitled, "The Disalienation of the Black Man". The rejection of the thesis led Fanon to seek to have the book published. It was the left wing philosopher Francis Jeanson, leader of the pro-Algerian independence, who insisted on the new title and also wrote an epilogue for this publication.
Algeria
Fanon left France for Algeria, where he had been stationed for some time during the war. He secured an appointment as a psychiatrist at Blida-Joinville Psychiatric Hospital. It was there that he radicalized methods of treatment. In particular, he began socio-therapy which connected with his patients' cultural backgrounds. He also trained nurses and interns. Following the outbreak of the Algerian revolution in November 1954 he joined the FLN liberation front (Front de Libération Nationale) as a result of contacts with Dr. Pierre Chaulet at Blida in 1955.
In The Wretched of the Earth (Les damnés de la terre), published shortly before Fanon's death in 1961, Fanon discusses in depth the effects on Algerians of torture by the French forces. His book was then censored by the French government.
Fanon made extensive trips across Algeria, mainly in the Kabyle region, to study the cultural and psychological life of Algerians. His lost study of "The marabout of Si Slimane" is an example. These trips were also a means for clandestine activities, notably in his visits to the ski resort of Chrea which hid an FLN base. By summer 1956 he wrote his "Letter of resignation to the Resident Minister" and made a clean break with his French assimilationist upbringing and education. He was expelled from Algeria in January 1957 and the "nest of fellaghas [rebels]" at Blida hospital was dismantled.
Fanon left for France and subsequently traveled secretly to Tunis. He was part of the editorial collective of El Moudjahid for which he wrote to the end of his life. He also served as Ambassador to Ghana for the Provisional Algerian Government and attended conferences in Accra, Conakry, Addis Ababa, Leopoldville, Cairo and Tripoli. Many of his shorter writings from this period were collected posthumously in the book Toward the African Revolution. In this book Fanon reveals himself as a war strategist; in one chapter he discusses how to open a southern front to the war and how to run the supply lines.
Death
On his return to Tunis, after his exhausting trip across the Sahara
to open a Third Front, Fanon was diagnosed with leukemia. He went to the Soviet Union for treatment and experienced some remission of his illness. On his return to Tunis he dictated his testament The Wretched of the EarthThe Wretched of the Earth. When he was not confined to his bed, he delivered lectures to ALN (Armée de Libération Nationale) officers at Ghardimao on the Algero-Tunisian border. He made a final visit to Sartre in Rome and went for further leukemia treatment in the USA.
He died in Bethesda, Maryland, on December 6, 1961 under the name of Ibrahim Fanon. He was buried in Algeria, after lying in state in Tunisia. Later his body was moved to a martyrs (chouhada) graveyard at Ain Kerma
in eastern Algeria. Fanon was survived by his wife Josie (née Dublé), their son Olivier, and his daughter (from a previous relationship) Mireille. Mireille married Bernard Mendès-France, son of the French politician Pierre Mendès-France. Josie committed suicide in Algiers in 1989.
Work
Although Fanon wrote Black Skin, White Masks while still in France, most of his work was written while in North Africa. It was during this time that he produced works such as L'An Cinq, de la Révolution Algérienne, or Year Five of the Algerian Revolution, later republished as 'Sociology of a Revolution" and later still as 'A Dying Colonialism'. The irony of this was that Fanon's original title was "Reality of a Nation", however the publisher, Francois Maspero, refused to accept this title. He also wrote an important work on decolonization. The Wretched of the Earth was first published in 1961 by François Maspero and has a preface by Jean-Paul Sartre. In it Fanon analyzes the role of class, race, national culture and violence in the struggle for national liberation. Both books established Fanon in the eyes of much of the Third World as the leading anti-colonial thinker of the 20th century.
Fanon's three books were supplemented by numerous psychiatry articles as well as radical critiques of French colonialism in journals such as Esprit and El Moudjahid.
The reception of his work has been affected by English translations which are recognized to contain numerous omissions and errors, while his unpublished work, including his doctoral thesis, has received little attention. As a result, Fanon has often been portrayed as an advocate of violence. This reductionist vision of Fanon's work ignores the subtlety of his understanding of the colonial system.
For Fanon in The Wretched of the Earth, the colonizer's presence in Algeria is based sheerly on military strength. Any resistance to this strength must also be of a violent nature because it is the only 'language' the colonizer speaks. The relevance of language and the reformation of discourse pervades much of his work, which is why it is so interdisciplinary, spanning psychiatric concerns to encompass politics, sociology, anthropology, linguistics and literature.
His participation in the Algerian FLN from 1955 determined his audience as the Algerian colonized. It was to them that his final work, Les damnés de la terre (translated into English by Constance Farrington as The Wretched of the Earth) was directed. It constitutes a warning to the oppressed of the dangers they face in the whirlwind of decolonization and the transition to a neo-colonialist/globalized world.
Influences
Much of Fanon's writings is traced to the influence of Aimé Césaire. But, while it could be said that Fanon's works are directly influenced by the Négritude movement, Fanon reformulated the theory of Césaire and Léopold Senghor by positing a new theory of consciousness. Négritude implicitly based consciousness in racial difference and tension. A mean to achieve equality and remain under French rule without losing one’s identity through assimilation. Fanon's psychological training and experience influenced him to base much of the problems he saw as psychological and as the product of the domination which arises in oppressive colonial situations. That is, consciousness was not of "racial essence" but a fact arising from political and social situations. Fanon's consciousness was not purely black, but extended to colonized peoples of any racial category. Fanon's own explanation of the difference between his theory and that of Blaise Diagne, Senghor and Césaire was based in an evolutionary model where the colonized ideologies transition from assimiliationist, négritude, and finally Fanon's own theory.
Influence
Fanon has had an influence on anti-colonial and national liberation movements. In particular, Les damnés de la terre was a major influence on the work of revolutionary leaders such as Ali Shariati in Iran, Steve Biko in South Africa, Malcolm X in the United States and Ernesto Che Guevara in Cuba. Of these only Guevara was primarily concerned with Fanon's theories on violence; for Shariati and Biko the main interest in Fanon was "the new man" and "black consciousness" respectively. Fanon's influence extended to the liberation movements of the Palestinians, the Tamils and others. His work was a key influence on the Black Panther Party. More recently, radical South African people's movements have been influenced by Fanon's work. His work was a key influence on Brazilian educationist Paulo Freire. Barack Obama references Fanon in his book, Dreams From My Father."
I have no reason to doubt the veracity of the biographical portion of this article. I cannot say the same with the analysis part of the article.
Before proceeding with my analysis of Lewis's article and its connection to Fanon, one term in the biographical article has to be defined: critical theory. The term "critical theory," at times, is improperly used as a general term describing any theory founded on critique. However, in its proper context, critical theory is a Marxist theory that draws upon all of the social sciences and humanities in making a critique of society and culture. The "theory" part is somewhat of a misnomer since Marxism, as a general rule, does not rely on science or the scientific method, especially with regards to economics.
Now that you have a background on Fanon, we will discuss his theories in my next post. In the meantime, should you want to read Fanon, you can find the full text of The Wretched of the Earth here: http://www.questia.com/PM.qst?a=o&d=9701586.
Labels:
Anti-colonialism,
Anti-imperialism,
Barack Obama,
Frantz Fanon,
Marxist
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)