Thomas Paine

Saturday, January 15, 2011

Why our nation never learns from the mistakes of the past: Case Study One - Government-backed home mortgages

From Henry Hazlitt, Economic in One Lesson:

"The case against government-guaranteed loans and mortgages to private businesses and persons is almost as strong as, though less obvious than, the case against direct government loans and mortgages. The advocates of government-guarantee mortgages also forget that what is being lent is ultimately real capital, which is limited in supply, and that they are helping identified B at the expense of some unidentified A. Government-guarantee home mortgages, especially when a neglible down payment or no down payment or no down payment, whatever is required, inevitably means more bad loans than otherwise. They force the general taxpayer to subsidize the bad risks and to defray the losses. They encourage people to "buy" houses that they cannot really afford. They tend eventually to bring about an oversupply of houses as compared with other things. They temporarily overstimulate building, raise the cost of building for everybody (including the buyers of the homes with the guaranteed mortgages), and may mislead the building industry into an eventually costly overexpansion. In brief, in the long run they do not increase overall national production but encourage malinvestment."

Sounds like a nice and consise summary of the subprime meltdown/housing market crisis right, right? You would think that until you learn that this was written IN 1946..

The role of government subsidies in the recent housing crisis is fully detailed in Thomas Sowell's Housing Boom and Bust. However, suffice it to say that the government, through the Federal Reserve, artificially reduced interest rates to all time lows instead of letting those interest rates be determined by market forces which lean toward the most efficient distribution of capital (capital, in this case, being the money that is invested by banks in the form of mortgage loans); expanded the role of Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac in purchasing risky loans which encouraged banks to make more of them; gave incentives to banks to give home loans to low-income applicants who, otherwise, would not have been able to afford those loans (the results of which are apparent in the obscene amount of foreclosures) and, in fact, threatened them with litigation should they fail to gave a certain proportion of loans to minorities; and, indirectly, created a market for investment products that betted against mortgagors' abilities to make their payments on those risky loans.

Both political parties bear some of the blame. The mistakes of the Clinton administration are well-documented, but President George W. Bush also pushed the idea of home ownership for all and Sen. Mitch McConnell suggested "providing government-backed, 4% fixed mortgage to any creditworthy borrower." Sen. Barbara Boxer advocated on behalf of, Sen. Harry Reid endorces, and Congressmen John Conyers and Dick Durbin introduced legislation, to allow bankruptcy judges to modify loans on principal residences. As Sowell notes and as Hazlitt points out repeatedly in his discussion of the fallacy of failing to look at long-term consequences, "how empowering judges to void legally-binding contracts would affect the future willingness of lenders to lend to millions of other people was a subject not addressed." Warnings were given by a number of credible sources. The Economist warned in 2003 that US house prices would fall 10% within the next four years and, in 2005, warned again that US house prices had reached "dangerous levels" and that the whole world economy was at risk. In 2003, then U.S. Secretary of the Treasury John W. Snow asked Congress to "enact legislation to create a new Federal agency to regulate and supervise" Fannie and Freddie. Snow was prophetic: in 2005, he testified before the same Congressional committee that securities issued by Fannie and Freddie were "out there in the marketplace, held by all sorts of financial institutions - insurance companies, pension plans, community banks, thrifts [and] commercial banks" and that "if something unravels, it could cause systemic risk to the whole financial system." In 2003, Robert J. Samuelson, a Newsweek columnist wrote that about 3000 banks held Fannie and Freddie "debt equal to all their capital." There were many more warnings, all of which went unheeded as homeowners basked in the warm glow of first-time home ownership or having bought their dream home. Congress didn't get it until the crash had occurred. Then, suddenly, every one of them that was involved in the problem, became a bunch of know-nothings or sought ways to blame their political opponents.

Sarah Palin is wrong for using the term "blood libel"

For the record, Sarah Palin exercised very poor judgment in choosing use such an emotionally charged term like "blood libel" to describe how she was being blamed by the Left for the recent Arizona shooting deaths. The media has, indeed, been slanderous and libelous, but why inject a term that offends so many Jews? For a definition of why the term is so offensive to Jews, click this link which gives an exhaustive history of the term, including its origins and instances of blood libel claims over the centuries: http://www.zionism-israel.com/dic/blood_libel.htm. The only possible reasoning I can see behind it is that Palin is trying to identify herself (and other conservatives) with the conditions and suffering of Jews who, over the years, were blamed for murders they didn't commit. It certainly is hyperbole on her part and I wonder who was the staff member or speech writer that suggested she use the term or included it in the speech she read.

Hezbollah withdraws from Lebanese government

I just read an AP piece from last Wednesday that reported that Hezbollah representatives withdrew from the Lebanese government over a U.S.-backed faction's insistence on initiating tribunals over the 2005 car bombing death of former prime minister Rafik Hariri. The opposing faction is led by Hariri's son, Saad. The move is expected to cause the Lebanese government to devolve into a state of chaos.

3 points:

1. Is chaos worse than having members of a terrorist organization controlling your government?

2. The AP reporters that authored this piece made an interesting observation: "The U.S. classifies Hezbollah as a terrorist organization." Although that statement is true, it also presumes that there are people who do NOT consider Hezbollah to be a terrorist organization. If the authors weren't making that presumption, then why not just say "Hezbollah is an Iranian-backed terrorist organization?" Similarly, it implies (or, rather, I infer) that Hezbollah is a terrorist organization because of our country's system of classification and not because Hezbollah sets of car bombs, engages in hijacking and kidnapping, and otherwise performs the functions of a terrorist organization.

3. One sentence contained in the piece is particularly telling: "France, Lebanon's former colonial power, is a major player in Lebanese politics."
This short sentence explains so much...

Friday, January 14, 2011

Thom Hartmann Compares Beck and O'Reilly to Bin Laden - Says their intentions are to activate lone wolf terrorists

I've heard of this guy, but never listened to his show. Now I see why. I'm trying to find the origin of this term or, at least, who was the first to apply it to conservative talk radio hosts. Hartmann probably got it from the DailyKos where G2Geek used it in a January 10, 2001: "Stochastic terrorism is the use of mass communications to stir up random lone wolves to carry out violent or terrorist acts that are statistically predictable but individually unpredictable." http://www.dailykos.com/story/2011/1/10/934890/-Stochastic-Terrorism:Triggering-the-shooters. I could spend my time addressing the Left's lunacy, but I found this post FROM HARTMANN'S OWN BLOG, that does the topic justice:

(from rickrack)
"I've searched the internet for Thom's claim that the FBI has used the term "stochastic terrorism." Please find a reference for that claim. I couldn't. The FBI has used stochastic processes for DNA analysis and risk assessment. Both may be related to terrorism but do not mean what Thom means: broadcasting a message that incites bin Laden's minions or the crazies to violent acts.

It's a wonderful meme but I think you should leave the FBI out of it. I watched the ex-FBI chief of the behavioral sciences unit on the Charlie Rose show. He is much more inclined to the mental illness theory Thom advocated yesterday without linking it to the catalyst of hate speech. Although liberal negative speech (Thom doesn't want to call it hate speech but it often appears to be such) hasn't been linked to violence lately, it would take just one crazy person who has a book by Thom Hartmann or Noam Chomsky in his library and then goes out to shoot up a bank or a former job office or school to make it a moot point. You can't depend on schizophrenics to restrict their violence to the right-wing point of view. That's crazy!

Stochastic terrorism is an excellent talk show talking point but meaningless or even dangerous in the long run. If 1 out of a million people acts on the message being broadcast, that's pretty low odds for advertising. It wouldn't sell many products. If we held those who write books accountable for the thoughts of those who then act violently, we might find that even the most innocuous children's books should be banned.

Even what I'm writing now might embolden some pure leftist to write a political tract advocating violence against some authority figure or institution. Should I then be held responsible for what I've written. Should I have self-consored this comment and not written it?"

In short, hey Lefties: stop inventing terms in a woefully inadequate attempt to sound intelligent when you libel those on the Right. Will anyone call them on their stupidity? Aren't these the same people that defend to the death a rapper's right to use the n-word in every sentence of every lyric, call all women b!tches and hoes, advocate the murder of policemen, and commit a number of other atrocities to women, homosexuals, white people, and President Bush? Talking about hypocrisy...

Wednesday, January 12, 2011

The Left is nothing but a warm and fuzzy ball of goodness and light. Ok, not really...

The Pima County Sheriff Department knew that Loughner made previous death threats

Could it be that Pima County Sheriff Dupnik's putting the blame on Rush Limbaugh and call to end the violent rhetoric was a ploy to cover up his own department's failure to act?

I'M BACK!

After spending too much time blogging/commenting on other websites, I realized a few things: 1) I was spending too much blogging on other websites; 2) the format on many of those sites is very similar to a chat room in that you have very limited space to make a meaningful post, you spend much of your time trying to limit the amount of characters you use via abbreviations, acronyms, etc., and the temptation is to just take potshots at the post to which you are responding because of the limitations on size; and 3) people on the Left are not willing to set aside their ideologies and listen to facts. This fact is no better displayed then in the reactions of the Left to the horrific events in Arizona this past weekend. The immediate response of the Leftist media was to blame the Right, even though there were absolutely no facts to support a finding that the shooter, Jared Lee Loughner, was motivated by anything he heard, saw, or read from the Right. Others took a different tact: instead of directly blaming the Right and conservative media, they attributed it to vitriolic rhetoric. "Vitriolic rhetoric" is the Left's way of saying: "the Right" or "conservative media." A nine year old girl and 5 other people died, for God's sake. 12 other people were wounded. Show some respect. Don't try to capitalize on their misery for political gain, especially when you have to grope blindly in the dark to find something worthwhile to include in your idiotic screeds.

Speaking of being opportunistic, it took less than a day for the Progressives to give their typical response: guns and certain words and symbols (not people, mind you, but guns and free speech) kill people, so we have to ban them. Rep. Carolyn McCarthy said that she was going to introduce a bill this past Monday (she made this comment on Sunday) that would impose stricter bans on handguns. Do you think she might have already drafted that bill and kept it tucked away somewhere waiting for the right opportunity? Do you think that her staff was able to, during the weekend and after the shooting (basically on a Sunday), just pull that bill out of thin air? As "Dead Fish" Rahm Emanuel would say: "Never let a good crisis go to waste." Rep. Bob Brady (D-PA) thought that it was a good idea to introduce legislation that would make it a federal crime to use language or symbols that could be perceived as threatening or inciting violence against a federal official or member of Congress. Now, no one wants anyone to threaten or incite violence against a federal official, but Congressman Brady seems to not understand that he is trampling on the First Amendment when he suggests that. By the way, Congressman, who is going to be the person that makes the decision? A Commerce Department bureaucrat? Someone who will be part of a new agency called, perhaps, the Federal Bureau of Dangerous Language and Symbols? A little too Orwellian for me, thank you.

I realized very quickly after this weekend that I had had enough of endless arguing with liberals who fail to set aside their scripts and talking points long enough to survey the evidence. It was time to make a change. In short, it is very, VERY good to be back and I look forward to being able to rant with abandon and achieve a modicum of catharsis by posting again on this blog. Come join me!